Safety first: Lower in added sugar, not sugar-free. Not medical or nutrition advice; check with your doctor about your own diet. Please read our editorial guidelines before you start.
Key takeaways
- Mash by hand or with a ricer and stop when it is smooth, because overworked potato turns gluey.
- Warm the milk with the butter and thyme first, so it goes in hot and the mash stays fluffy.
- To make it ahead, add 1/4 cup extra milk, chill it covered for up to 2 days and reheat covered to 165°F.
In this post5 sections
What we found, and what we are guessing
We read three pages in full (Cooking Classy, The Endless Meal and America's Test Kitchen, all under Sources or linked below) and saw four more in search results (Half Baked Harvest, Fox and Briar, Sweet and Savory by Shinee and The Defined Dish). They agree on roasting the garlic at 400°F for about 40 to 45 minutes in foil, warming the dairy before it goes in, and that mashed potatoes can be made 1 to 3 days ahead and reheated covered at 350°F. They differ on the potato (red, Yukon Gold or russet), on how much butter and cream (from 2 tablespoons to a quarter cup each) and on freezing. The complaints that came up were reheated mash that dries out, a gluey mash from overworking it or from waxy potatoes, and a cold glass dish that can crack in a hot oven. The comments we could read had few other complaints. The fixes: make the mash slightly looser before chilling, mash gently, and let a cold dish sit out 30 minutes before the oven. We kept the russet potatoes, the thyme milk and the garlic from our reel. The hand-mashing, the extra milk for make-ahead, the 165°F check and the fridge times are our additions.
Watch the reel by @shelby.austinn on Instagram
Make it ahead for Thanksgiving
Thanksgiving is Thursday, November 26, so you can make this on Tuesday or Wednesday. Roast the garlic, make the mash with the extra 1/4 cup milk, let it cool, then spoon it into a buttered baking dish, cover it tightly with foil and chill it. We would keep it to 2 days in the fridge, a little under the 3 days some of the pages we read allow.
On Thursday, take the dish out of the fridge 30 minutes before it goes in the oven, so a glass or ceramic dish does not crack from the heat. Bake it covered at 350°F for 35 to 45 minutes, until it reads 165°F in the center on an instant-read thermometer, which is the USDA safe temperature for reheated leftovers. Stir in a splash of warm milk if it looks stiff. If the oven is busy with the turkey, use the microwave: a covered, vented bowl at 75 percent power in 2-minute bursts, stirring each time, until 165°F. Anything left after dinner keeps 3 to 4 days in the fridge.
Tested recipe
Roasted Garlic Mashed Potatoes
Russet potatoes mashed by hand with roasted garlic, warm thyme milk and a little butter, finished with olive oil. Serves 6 as a side, with a make-ahead plan.
Ingredients
Roasted garlic
- 1 whole head of garlic, the papery skin left on
- 1 tsp olive oil
- 1 pinch kosher salt
Potatoes
- 3 lb russet potatoes, about 4 large; peeled and cut into 2-inch chunks
- 2 tsp kosher salt, for the cooking water
Thyme milk
- 1 cup whole milk, plus 1/4 cup more if you are making it ahead
- 2 Tbsp butter
- 3 sprigs fresh thyme
- 1/2 tsp Creole seasoning, optional; it is salty, so taste before adding more salt
To finish
- 1 Tbsp + 2 tsp olive oil, the rest of the 2 Tbsp
- 1 tsp kosher salt, plus more to taste
- 1/4 tsp black pepper
- thyme leaves, a few, for the top
Steps
Step pictures are AI illustrations, not our dish. Our photos are coming after we cook it.
-
Heat the oven to 400°F. Slice about 1/4 inch off the top of the garlic head so the cloves show. Set it on a square of foil, drizzle with 1 tsp olive oil, add a pinch of salt and wrap it closed. Roast 35 to 45 minutes, until the cloves are golden and soft when pressed. Let it cool 10 minutes before squeezing.
AI illustration -
While the garlic roasts, peel the potatoes and cut them into even 2-inch chunks so they cook at the same speed. Put them in a large pot, cover with cold water by 1 inch and add 2 tsp salt.
AI illustration -
Bring to a boil, turn the heat down to a gentle simmer and cook 15 to 20 minutes, until a fork slides in with no resistance. Drain well in a colander, then return the potatoes to the dry hot pot over low heat for 1 minute so the steam dries them off.
AI illustration -
While the potatoes simmer, warm the milk, butter, thyme and Creole seasoning in a small saucepan over low heat for about 5 minutes, until the butter melts and the milk is steaming but not boiling. Take out the thyme sprigs.
AI illustration -
Squeeze the roasted garlic cloves out of their skins onto the potatoes. Mash with a hand masher or press through a ricer, then pour in the warm milk in 3 additions, folding gently after each until smooth. Do not use a blender or food processor, which turns the starch gluey. Stir in 1 tsp salt and the pepper, taste and add more salt if needed.
AI illustration -
Drizzle the remaining 1 Tbsp + 2 tsp olive oil over the top, scatter a few thyme leaves and serve hot. Keep warm, covered, for up to 30 minutes if the rest of dinner is not ready.
AI illustration
Notes
- Contains milk (the milk and butter).
- Russet potatoes mash light and fluffy. Waxy red potatoes and overworking the mash make it gluey, so mash by hand and stop when it is smooth.
- For Thanksgiving, make it 1 to 2 days ahead using the extra 1/4 cup milk, so it stays creamy when reheated. The plan is in the make-ahead section above the recipe card.
- Reheat leftovers to 165°F, the USDA safe temperature, checked with an instant-read thermometer in the center.
- The reel says about 1 hour, mostly hands-off roasting. Our estimate is 60 minutes in all, about 25 of them hands-on.
- No sugar is added to this recipe: 0 g of added sugar. The card total sugar (4 g a serving) is natural sugar from the potato, garlic and milk. We make no lower-sugar claim because we did not compare against a specific version. Worked by hand from the ingredient lists; no online calculator was used.
- Every amount and time here is our estimate.
Swaps
- Use Yukon Gold potatoes for a denser, creamier mash; untested.
- Use half-and-half instead of the milk for a richer mash; untested.
- Use a dairy-free butter and unsweetened plain oat milk for a milk-free version; untested.
Storage and reheating
Storage: Cool the potatoes and put them in the fridge within 2 hours of cooking. Leftover mashed potatoes keep 3 to 4 days in a covered container in the fridge (USDA). For a holiday, we make them up to 2 days ahead. Keep the roasted garlic in the fridge, covered, and use it within 2 days; never leave garlic in oil at room temperature. We have not tested freezing; for best quality, plan to use frozen mash within 2 months and thaw it overnight in the fridge.
Reheating: Oven: spoon into a buttered baking dish, cover tightly with foil and bake at 350°F for 35 to 45 minutes, stirring once if you can, until 165°F in the center. Stovetop: low heat in a saucepan with a splash of milk, stirring often. Microwave: a covered bowl with a vent at 75 percent power in 2-minute bursts, stirring each time, until 165°F.
Nutrition (1 serving (about 1 cup))
- Calories: 250 calories
- Carbs: 36 g
- Sugar: 4 g
- Fiber: 5 g
- Protein: 5 g
- Fat: 10 g
- Sodium: 423 mg
Estimates only, summed from standard USDA SR Legacy values per ingredient. Not medical or nutrition advice.
Where this recipe comes from
- Inspired by Roasted Garlic Mashed Potatoes from Cooking Classy, which we used for roasting the garlic at 400°F in foil with a little oil, warming the milk and butter before mixing, and reheating covered at 350°F, and by Make-Ahead Mashed Potatoes from The Endless Meal, which we used for making the mash a little looser before chilling and letting a cold dish warm up before it goes into a hot oven.
- Make-ahead timing also drew on How to Make Mashed Potatoes Ahead from America's Test Kitchen, which we used for making the mash a little looser before chilling and for a covered, vented microwave reheat, with about 2 days in the fridge.
- The idea came from this reel by @shelby.austinn.
How to serve it
Serve hot with roast chicken or turkey and gravy, or with a green vegetable such as tuscan parmesan peas on the side. The roasted garlic is mild and sweet, so you can add a second head if your family likes it stronger.
Every recipe from Diane's reels in one printable book: the Healthy Recipes Cookbook.
Frequently asked questions
Why are my mashed potatoes gluey?
Usually the starch was overworked, for example in a blender, food processor or with a lot of whipping, or the potato was a waxy red type. Mash by hand or with a ricer, fold in the warm milk gently and stop when it is smooth.
How far ahead can I make them?
We would make them up to 2 days ahead with 1/4 cup extra milk, chilled in a covered baking dish, and reheat to 165°F. Leftovers keep 3 to 4 days in the fridge (USDA).
Can I roast the garlic ahead?
Yes, up to 2 days ahead. Keep it covered in the fridge. Do not leave garlic in oil at room temperature.

Save it for later
Pin this to your Sides & Salads board so it's there when you need it.
Save to Pinterest





